Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Understanding the New York City Mansion Tax

Understanding the New York City Mansion Tax

New York law mandates a single payment at closing for residential acquisitions priced at $1 million or higher, widely referred to as the mansion tax. Despite the name, this levy can apply to a wide variety of homes, not just luxury estates. It is important for prospective owners to understand how this tax is triggered and how it impacts the total cost of a transaction. If you need to learn more about the NYC mansion tax, visit the firm's website.

Core Concepts of the Mansion Tax

The Million-Dollar Threshold

The tax applies to residential property transfers where the price reaches $1 million or more. This amount serves as the floor for the tax. While the name implies a focus on luxury, the levy applies to a range of residences, such as Manhattan co-ops, condos, and houses that meet the minimum price.

Progressive Rate Tiers

The tax rate is not a flat percentage. Instead, it uses a tiered system where the rate increases as the purchase price rises. The percentage is calculated based on the entire transaction amount rather than just the sum that surpasses a specific bracket boundary. Since the percentage applies to the total amount, crossing a threshold by even a tiny margin shifts the entire sale into a higher tier, which can lead to a substantial change in the final tax amount. Buyers should be aware of these thresholds when negotiating a contract.

Defining Residential Property

This requirement is relevant to buyers of co-ops, singular condominium units, or structures housing between one and three families. Properties consisting of four or more residential dwellings fall outside the classification of residential real property for this particular tax rule. Therefore, purchasing an entire building of that size is not subject to the levy, although purchasing an individual unit within such a building might still trigger it.

Payment Obligations

At the time of closing, the grantee—or the buyer—must provide the payment for this tax. While a seller or a developer might offer a credit to help cover the expense, this does not alter the buyer's legal duty to the state. If the purchaser neglects to settle this obligation, both parties to the transaction share legal responsibility for the debt, as established by New York Tax Law § 1402-a(b).

Cost Basis Considerations

This tax is not deductible on federal income tax returns. However, it does play a role in long-term financial planning. Buyers are permitted to add the amount paid for the tax to the cost basis of their property. This can be beneficial when calculating capital gains if the property is sold in the future, as it may lower the taxable gain.

Filing Requirements

The filing process is a necessary part of the closing. Buyers, or the professionals representing them, must complete Form TP-584-NYC, which serves as the official tax return for the transfer. If this document is not filed or the payment is not made on time, it can lead to penalties or interest charges.

For the full detail, including the exceptions, see the guidance from a qualified NYC real estate attorney.

About the author

Peter Zinkovetsky is the Managing Partner of Avenue Law Firm. He earned a Bachelor of Business Administration Degree in Finance from Pace University and a Juris Doctor Degree from New York Law School, and is admitted in New York and in the US District Court for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York. He has been named a Rising Star by Super Lawyers for eight years in a row.

Visit our Manhattan office

Avenue Law Firm, 505 Park Ave #1201, New York, NY 10022. Call (212) 729-4090 to schedule a consultation.

Contact the firm online

Also on this blog: Reviewing a NYC Co-op Before You Buy and Steps After Accepted Offer on House in New York: A Primer.

Related reading: Manhattan co-op attorney.

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation.

Monday, October 12, 2026

Steps After Accepted Offer on House in New York: A Primer

Steps After Accepted Offer on House in New York: A Primer

In New York City, an accepted offer is merely the beginning of the legal process, not the finish line. A deal sheet outlines the basic terms, but these details must be formalized into a binding contract to protect both the buyer and the seller. This period involves careful negotiation, financial verification, and property investigations before the transaction can move toward a final closing. For more detail, you can speak with the firm's real estate attorneys in New York.

Key Concepts in the New York Real Estate Process

The Written Contract

New York law mandates that agreements for the sale of property must be in writing to be enforceable. A handshake or verbal agreement does not create a binding obligation. Once an offer is accepted, the seller’s legal counsel drafts the formal contract. The buyer’s counsel then reviews this document, negotiating terms such as the closing date, conditions for cancellation, and what personal property is included. Only after both parties have signed and delivered this document are they legally bound.

The Contract Deposit

Buyers typically provide a deposit when signing the contract, often totaling 10% of the total purchase price. This money functions as a sign of good faith and is held in an escrow account, usually managed by the seller’s attorney. The funds remain there until the transaction concludes or is terminated. The contract specifies what happens to this money if the deal does not reach the finish line, such as when a contingency fails or if a party defaults.

Mortgage Contingency

Many buyers rely on loans to fund their purchase. A mortgage contingency clause provides a safety net, allowing the buyer to cancel the contract and receive their deposit back if they cannot secure financing despite making a diligent effort. This protection typically lasts for a specified number of days. If the lender denies the loan within this window, the buyer can exit the agreement. Missing these deadlines can jeopardize the buyer’s rights, making prompt action essential.

Title Report

A title search is conducted to ensure the property is free of hidden problems. The resulting report outlines the ownership history and reveals potential issues like unpaid taxes, liens, or building code violations. The title company uses schedules to organize this information. Schedule B is particularly important, as it lists the requirements that must be cleared before the policy is issued, as well as exceptions—matters that the insurance policy will not cover.

Final Walk-through

Before the official closing, the buyer performs a final visit to the property. This step occurs shortly before the transfer of ownership to ensure the home remains in the condition agreed upon in the contract. It confirms that appliances are functional, agreed-upon repairs were finished, and no new damage has occurred. If problems are discovered during this visit, they are generally resolved through negotiations, such as price adjustments or credits, before the final documents are signed.

The process of moving from an accepted offer to a completed sale involves many moving parts and potential pitfalls. Understanding these elements can help buyers and sellers navigate the transition smoothly. For the full detail, including the exceptions, consult with real estate attorneys in New York.

Manhattan What Happens After Your Offer Is Accepted - Avenue Law Firm

Watch on YouTube: What Happens After Your Offer Is Accepted on a House in New York by Peter Zinkovetsky

About the author

Peter Zinkovetsky is the Managing Partner of Avenue Law Firm. He earned a Bachelor of Business Administration Degree in Finance from Pace University and a Juris Doctor Degree from New York Law School, and is admitted in New York and in the US District Court for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York. He has been named a Rising Star by Super Lawyers for eight years in a row.

Avenue Law Firm

505 Park Ave #1201, New York, NY 10022 · (212) 729-4090.

Contact the firm online

Also on this blog: NYC Real Estate Closing Checklist: Steps for Sellers.

Related reading: Manhattan real estate attorney.

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation.

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Reviewing a NYC Co-op Before You Buy

Reviewing a NYC Co-op Before You Buy

Purchasing a cooperative unit in New York City requires careful investigation of the building's internal records. Skipping this phase may expose you to unexpected debts or living restrictions that complicate your ownership experience. For more detail, you can speak with the firm's Manhattan co-op attorneys.

Due Diligence Checklist for Co-op Buyers

  1. Review the offering plan and subsequent amendments. This foundational document details share allocation and sponsor duties. Amendments are vital because they provide updated disclosures on budget changes or remaining sponsor holdings that the primary document might overlook.
  2. Scrutinize the proprietary lease and house regulations. These papers establish your daily living boundaries. They outline your obligations for repairs, what happens if you miss payments, and the rules governing subletting, guest policies, or home renovations.
  3. Analyze board meeting records from recent years. These notes often highlight building infrastructure challenges, neighbor conflicts, or pending projects not yet visible in financial reports. They offer a window into how the board manages its business and addresses resident concerns.
  4. Evaluate the building's overall financial health. Look for consistent income performance versus operating costs over several years. High levels of unpaid maintenance fees from shareholders can strain the cooperative's budget, even if the building appears stable.
  5. Check the status of reserve funds. A small cash buffer may force the board to borrow money or levy extra charges for necessary repairs. Consider these balances alongside the building's mortgage debt to gauge its economic stability.
  6. Investigate any legal disputes. Litigation can drain reserves or impact insurance coverage. Check board minutes and agent disclosures for information on construction defects, personal injury claims, or contractor disagreements that could affect your investment.
  7. Verify insurance coverage details. The cooperative maintains a master policy for the structure, but you must understand the deductible amounts. High deductibles might lead to assessments if the building must pay for damages out of pocket.
  8. Confirm compliance with municipal facade safety rules. For taller structures, a recent inspection report is mandatory. A classification indicating that work is necessary suggests that capital improvements and associated costs could be on the horizon.
  9. Conduct a thorough search for liens. Unlike real estate, co-ops are personal property. This search uncovers any judgments, tax liens, or bankruptcy issues attached to the seller that could cloud the transfer of your shares.

For the full detail, including the exceptions, read the piece from our Manhattan co-op attorneys.

Manhattan What Should a Buyer Review Before Purchasin - Avenue Law Firm

Watch on YouTube: What Should a Buyer Review Before Purchasing a NYC Co-op? by Peter Zinkovetsky

About the author

Peter Zinkovetsky is the Managing Partner of Avenue Law Firm. He earned a Bachelor of Business Administration Degree in Finance from Pace University and a Juris Doctor Degree from New York Law School, and is admitted in New York and in the US District Court for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York. He has been named a Rising Star by Super Lawyers for eight years in a row.

Where to find us

Avenue Law Firm is at 505 Park Ave #1201, New York, NY 10022, and the phone is (212) 729-4090.

Contact the firm online

Also on this blog: NYC Real Estate Closing Checklist: Steps for Sellers and Steps After Accepted Offer on House in New York: A Primer.

Related reading: Manhattan Co-op Real Estate Attorney.

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation.

Wednesday, September 30, 2026

NYC Real Estate Closing Checklist: Steps for Sellers

NYC Real Estate Closing Checklist: Steps for Sellers

Selling real estate in New York City involves several specific legal and practical obligations that start the moment you accept an offer. Navigating these requirements successfully requires attention to detail, as errors in documentation or failure to address building rules early can often delay your closing date or create unforeseen financial liabilities.

Whether you are selling a house, a condominium, or a co-op, the process involves a series of transitions from contract preparation to the final exchange of keys. Understanding these steps helps you manage expectations and ensures you have the necessary information ready when your attorney and other parties request it.

A Seller’s Action Checklist for NYC Closings

  1. Retain a real estate attorney and prepare the deal sheet. While New York law does not impose a blanket requirement for legal representation, an attorney typically prepares the contract of sale, gathers ownership information, and manages legal issues. If a broker is involved, they often create a deal sheet summarizing agreed terms such as the price, deposit, and financing contingencies, which your attorney can then review for inconsistencies before the contract is executed.
  2. Clear title and mortgage liens. A title report often reveals recorded ownership issues, unpaid taxes, or money judgments that need attention before closing. You must work with your attorney to address these items, which might involve paying off existing mortgages, closing home equity lines, or providing affidavits to the title company to resolve objections.
  3. Complete mandatory legal disclosures. You may be required to provide specific disclosures before the buyer is bound by the contract. For one- to four-family residential properties, this often includes the Property Condition Disclosure Statement, while federal law requires sellers of most housing built before 1978 to disclose known lead-based paint hazards and provide the EPA pamphlet.
  4. Prepare and file necessary transfer tax forms. Depending on the sale price and property type, you will likely need to file various tax returns, such as form TP-584-NYC for state real estate transfer taxes. Because the seller is often primarily liable for base transfer taxes and the NYC Real Property Transfer Tax, your attorney should calculate these charges and coordinate the filing of the required forms with the closing package.
  5. Address condominium or co-op transfer requirements. If you are selling a unit in a building, you must follow the governing bylaws and board requirements. For a condominium, this might involve obtaining a waiver if the board has a right of first refusal, while a co-op closing often requires coordinated delivery of the stock certificate, proprietary lease, and board consent to the transfer.
  6. Conduct the final walk-through. Before closing, the buyer will inspect the property to confirm it meets the condition required by the contract and that all included fixtures remain in place. You should schedule your move-out to account for building-specific requirements like elevator reservations or insurance certificates, as any issues identified during this walk-through may need to be resolved before the transaction can proceed.
  7. Review the closing statement and disbursement instructions. Your attorney will prepare or review the closing statement, which details the gross sale price, adjustments for prorated taxes or maintenance, and net proceeds. Before closing, ensure you have provided your attorney with the correct account information for wires and confirmed any instructions to avoid delays in receiving your funds.
  8. Organize your post-closing records. After the sale, maintain a complete set of documents, including your signed contract, the recorded deed or lease assignment, filed transfer tax returns, and records documenting the property’s adjusted basis. Keeping these files organized is necessary for federal and state tax reporting in the year of the sale.

For the full detail regarding these requirements and the exceptions that may apply to your specific transaction, see the full version on the firm's site.

About the author

Peter Zinkovetsky is the Managing Partner of Avenue Law Firm. He earned a Bachelor of Business Administration Degree in Finance from Pace University and a Juris Doctor Degree from New York Law School, and is admitted in New York and in the US District Court for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York. He has been named a Rising Star by Super Lawyers for seven consecutive years.

Visit our Manhattan office

Avenue Law Firm, 505 Park Ave #1201, New York, NY 10022. Call (212) 729-4090 to schedule a consultation.

Related reading: Manhattan co-op attorney.

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation.

Tuesday, May 9, 2023

Two Names on Deed, One on Mortgage – Who Owns the House?

Having shared property with someone is common, especially between spouses. It is also common to have the same bank accounts and even the same debts. However, this is not a universal experience and there may be some instances where both you and your spouse would be better off only including one name on the official document instead of sharing. 

Understanding the significance of when and which documents you include your and your spouse’s names can give you a better understanding of how title deeds and mortgages work in New York. Working with a skilled New York residential real estate attorney can also provide you with valuable insight on how to make sure your property documents are in accordance with the law and ensure that your rights are protected. To schedule a consultation with one of our qualified attorneys, call Avenue Law Firm today at (212) 729-4090.

Mortgage vs. Deed

To get a better understanding of how property ownership works in New York, it is important to first get a grasp of the differences between the mortgage and the deed. While both are legal documents concerned with real estate and can often be used interchangeably, they perform very different purposes. Knowing the difference between these two documents and what they represent can allow you to have better insight into how to protect your rights as well as to learn about the responsibilities and expectations required of you as a homeowner.

Title Deed

The title of the property represents its actual ownership. The ownership of a piece of real estate is often represented by a deed. When a house is purchased, the deed to the property should be transferred to the new owner through a deed conveyance to represent the change in ownership. The change in ownership should also be filed with the county’s Register’s Office. If there is a dispute regarding the ownership of the property, the deed would be the first place to look for confirmation of who the true owner is. People who are not listed on the title deed may have a hard time proving ownership due to the fact that they are not listed on the title.

Types of Multiple Property Ownership in New York 

A property can be owned by one or multiple people. It can also be held by a trust or a business. In New York, there are multiple ways in which a property can be owned by multiple parties.

Tenancy in Common 

In a Tenancy in Common, each owner has a right to sell, transfer, or borrow against their own interest in the whole property. An example can be when a deceased person passes on a piece of real property to more than one beneficiary in their will. If the tenants in common agree, they may be able to divide up their interests in the property and exchange it for a monetary value through filing an action for a “partition”. The court will divide up the interests and can ensure that each tenant in common will receive the value of their interest in the property.

Joint Tenancy

A Joint Tenancy may be somewhat like a Tenancy in Common, however, when an original party’s interest is sold, the ownership type becomes a Tenancy in Common. If one of the parties dies, however, their interest will automatically transfer to the other joint tenant. Joint Tenancy operates on a “right of survivorship”.

New York has 4 requirements for a Joint Tenancy with Rights of Survivorship (JTWROS):

  • All owners must have an equal share and stake in the property. When one owner dies, their stake in the property should be distributed evenly among the surviving owners. No owner is allowed to have a bigger share than the others.
  • No co-owner can limit any joint owner of their access to the property.
  • All owners must be able to show their interest in the property at the same time, with the same legal instrument such as the property’s deed
  • The joint tenancy must be established at the same time and no tenants with a right of survivorship can be added on the joint tenancy has been established.

A regular JTWROS may be severed even without the consent of the other property owners. This can be done in two ways:

  • By one of the co-owners conveying their joint tenancy interest to a third party, regardless if the third party is required to reconvey the tenancy interest to the severing co-owner
  • By one of the co-owners executing a written document (such as a quitclaim deed) of their interest to sever the joint tenancy. The document should include a deed naming the other joint tenant as the grantee of the severing co-owner’s tenancy interest 
Tenancy by the Entirety

A Tenancy by the Entirety is a special kind of Joint Tenancy for married couples. Owners in Tenancy by the Entirety enjoy the benefits of a Joint Tenancy along with the Right of Survivorship. However, the owners cannot file a petition to partition the property or transfer the property without both owners’ – the spouses’ – consent.

Mortgage

A mortgage loan represents a debt to the bank. As it is a secured debt, mortgages require an asset to act as leverage and assurance that the debt would be paid. In the event that the person who owes the mortgage cannot continue paying the bank, the bank can repossess the property. This ability to repossess the asset allows the lender – in this case, the bank – to minimize the risk of loss.

When there are two names on a title deed, it means that there are joint owners of the property and each person owns an equal share of the property. The mortgage does not need to include both names to be valid. Even if the mortgage only lists one spouse, it does not affect the share of the ownership of the property. 

Differences in Name Inclusion on Property Documents

So why do differences exist and why can two names be on a deed but only one name is included on the mortgage? There can be a few reasons why this is the case depending on when the home was bought and how the purchase was financed. Having both spouses’ names on the mortgage may be beneficial but this may not be ideal in some situations.

Interest Rates and Credit Score Impact

In cases where a spouse has a poor credit history, interest rates may become higher if they are included in the mortgage. The couple may opt to only include the spouse with the better credit score on the mortgage to be able to save up money on interest payments in the long run.

When foreclosure is imminent, the spouse whose name is on the mortgage would be the only one impacted. The other spouse would be able to apply for other financing options as their credit score would have not been affected by the foreclosure.

Income Requirements

Most real estate loans have income requirements. If a spouse has an income that does not meet the requirements, perhaps because they have not had an income due to the marriage or do not have a consistent income, it may be wise to leave them out of the mortgage application.

Marriage Dynamics

If the home is not intended to be bought for the use of both spouses, that is, one spouse is buying the house to be used after a pending divorce, it’s more prudent to include only one spouse’s name on the mortgage. If the house was acquired during the marriage, it may be considered marital property. The assistance of an experienced attorney may clarify things regarding how ownership would work in this scenario.

Differences in the inclusion of each spouse’s name on the title deed can also vary but it’s important to remember that ownership of the property is based on the inclusion of your name on the title deed. Some reasons why name inclusion on the title deed can differ in New York include the following:

  • The property was bought by one of the spouses before the marriage
  • Avoiding one spouse’s creditors who can file a claim against the spouse with poor credit to take the property as collateral
  • If you have a previous marriage and want to leave the property to family members from your previous marriage, including only your name on the title deed would make it easier to transfer the property 

Adding, Removing, and Transferring Property Interest

New York allows for a distinction between property owned before and during a marriage. When one spouse has property acquired before the marriage, ownership does not automatically become mutual upon marriage. Even after a divorce, only property that is considered marital property and mutually owned would be divided and distributed between spouses. However, there are ways in which a spouse can transfer some ownership interest in their solely owned property to their spouse during the marriage.

Adding your spouse to the title deed can be done to give them a share in the ownership of the property. This can be done through a quitclaim deed which gives your spouse property interest. Quitclaim deeds can also be useful in the following cases:

  • Giving a spouse ownership interest or making them a co-owner of the property after the marriage
  • Giving a spouse sole ownership of a property after a divorce
  • Transferring ownership of a property to a family member, such as an adult child
  • Transferring ownership of a property to a trust

A quitclaim deed only serves as proof that a person “quits” any claim they have on a property. Filing a quitclaim deed does not mean that the person who is given the original owner’s property interest would have sole ownership. It only means that they would be acquiring any existing interest or ownership share the original owner has on the property. For property co-owned by two or more persons, each person can only quit their claim on the percentage of ownership they have and it will not affect their co-owners’ share.

This also applies to any taxes on property transferred such as capital gains tax. Discussing who will be responsible for paying these taxes is important to avoid any complications.

It is important to note that quitclaim deeds are only useful for specific purposes. When buying a property, it is strongly recommended to undergo the proper conveyance procedures and ensure that the purchase agreement includes everyone intended to be the property owner. 

Mortgage After Divorce

A quitclaim deed also does not affect any liability on mortgages on the property. In the case of couples divorcing, if both spouses have their names on the deed and the mortgage, even if one spouse has quit their ownership claim on the property, they may still be responsible for the mortgage. A separation agreement may be helpful in ironing out any issues regarding who will be responsible for the mortgage. If one spouse gets the marital home after the divorce, they can refinance it and get a mortgage that is under their own name. This can help the spouse who did not get the home in the divorce to be able to move on with their life without the financial obligation.

If the couple is unable to come into a consensus regarding who will pay the mortgage and continue to have both their names on it even after the divorce, it can present a serious problem. If one spouse is not able to fulfill their obligation, it may be up to the other spouse to complete payments on the loan even if they are not living on the property. If the property ends up in foreclosure due to nonpayment of the debt, both spouses can suffer damages to their credit scores. Regardless of whose names are included on the deed, it is important to continue paying the mortgage to avoid the loss of the property through foreclosure.

Removing a Spouse From a Mortgage

Mortgages are an agreement between the borrower/s and the lender. It can be difficult to remove a spouse’s name on a mortgage without the lender agreeing, especially when it can mean that the lender is being deprived of one means to collect on the debt. Removing a spouse on a mortgage can only be done with the lender’s consent or through refinancing the home. 

Adding a spouse to a mortgage can also only be done through refinancing. This can be considerably complicated due to the fact that the spouse would need to be approved. 

If Your Name Is in the Mortgage but Not the Deed

If your name is not included in the title deed of the home but is included in the mortgage, this can mean that you do not have an ownership stake in the property while also being obligated to make payments to the mortgage. In this scenario, you have all the liability of having a mortgage named after you while none of the benefits of having an ownership stake in the property. 

Having only one name on the deed can also present an issue in terms of inheritance. If the spouse whose name on the deed passes away, it can present a succession issue on who will be able to get the property. In most cases, when both spouses are co-owners of the property as in a Joint Tenancy by the Entirety, a spouse automatically gets ownership of the property upon the other spouse’s death.

When there is only one name on the deed and the person dies, the property’s ownership will transfer depending on who the rightful beneficiary is as included in the person’s will or according to New York’s intestacy laws. This can mean that the deceased person’s spouse may not inherit the home.

For a mortgage, when the spouse on the mortgage dies, paying the outstanding debt will be done through their estate. The deceased person’s estate would have to continue paying the debt or risk the foreclosure of the home. The bank can also put a claim on other assets in the estate to ensure payment of the loan. To avoid this, the surviving spouse may enter a negotiation with the bank to refinance the mortgage under their own name.

Getting Professional Assistance For Your Real Estate Needs

Overall, discussing the matter of property ownership and the mortgage with your spouse, especially when you are not sure whether or not both of your names are on the title deed of your home is best done sooner rather than later. Ensuring that your property documents are in order can help you have a sense of security and prevent costly mistakes down the line.

Consult an experienced New York City real estate attorney to make sure your property documents reflect your real estate goals. An attorney can walk you through the potential complications and any issues you may encounter and provide the most applicable solutions. At Avenue Law Firm, our capable Manhattan attorneys have handled numerous real estate transactions in New York. Our attorneys provide tailored assistance that keeps our clients’ best interests in mind. Contact us today at (212) 729-4090 to schedule a consultation with one of our attorneys.



source https://www.avenuelawfirm.com/two-names-on-deed-one-on-mortgage-who-owns-the-house/

Thursday, May 4, 2023

What To Do in an Apartment Lease Buyout?

As a renter, the prospect of being tied down to an apartment lease, especially if the contract is extended, can be a daunting, but calculated risk. A renter should go into a lease knowing the terms and abide by them throughout the duration of the contract. If a renter wanted to get out of the lease early, they would have to pay a termination fee, lose their security deposit, or risk being taken to small claims court. On the flip side, landlords who want to end an existing apartment lease early or want a renter to move out before the lease is over can make an offer to buy out the existing lease.

While this may seem unbalanced, landlords are also bound to abide by the terms of a lease agreement. Just as landlords have rights, New York also has laws that protect the renter’s rights in the event that their landlord wants to end their lease agreement early. However, not everyone may be familiar with the inner workings of the law. Before you make any decisions, it is important to retain the services of a competent NYC real estate attorney. Working with a skilled real estate attorney can be beneficial in ensuring that your rights are protected in a buyout. Our experienced Manhattan residential real estate attorneys at Avenue Law Firm may be able to help you in ensuring that the terms of your buyout are favorable to you. Call us today to schedule a free consultation at (212) 729-4090.

Understanding an Apartment Lease Buyout

While apartment lease buyouts are not uncommon in New York, they can still take an inexperienced renter by surprise. Apartment lease buyouts occur when a landlord offers to pay a renter a lump sum in exchange for the renter moving out and are usually done by landlords in the hopes of getting a higher-paying tenant. 

Apartment lease buyouts happen more frequently in rent-controlled or rent-stabilized apartments, usually for the following reasons:

  • Rent increase caps
  • Laws allowing tenants to renew their leases

New York laws prohibit landlords from increasing rent above a certain cap annually as long as the same tenant remains in the apartment. Tenants are also allowed by NYC rent regulations to renew their apartment leases in perpetuity, meaning that they cannot be evicted due to their leases expiring. As long as the tenant follows the terms of the lease and pays their rent on time, they can be allowed to renew their lease until they choose to move out. 

While this may not always be the case, apartment lease buyouts usually occur more in areas of the city that are seeing more development. Development in terms of more job opportunities or commercial spaces can often mean that rent prices increase but NY laws protecting tenants in rent-controlled or rent-stabilized apartments make it difficult for landlords to evict tenants or impose a higher rent. There are also scenarios wherein the City or a developer offers to buy a landlord’s property. If there are remaining tenants, a landlord cannot sell their property.

A lease can only be broken if the tenant has not been following the terms or through mutual agreement. Through an apartment lease buyout, a landlord and tenant can work together to find terms that are mutually acceptable and end the lease agreement without issues.

The NYC Rent Guidelines Board oversees lease agreements and ensures that statutes and guidelines are followed both by landlords and tenants. While tenants face eviction if they do not follow the agreements, landlords themselves are subject to high fines and penalties if they abuse the agreements. Both parties are expected to adhere to New York City landlord-tenant laws which govern lease agreements.

Should You Accept or Negotiate?

If you have been offered a lease buyout by your landlord, it’s important to remember that you are not obligated to accept. You are well within your right to reject an offer, even if the buyout offer is high. 

A landlord also cannot coerce or harass you to accept a lease buyout offer. It’s illegal for a landlord to threaten you or otherwise cancel essential services to your apartment because you don’t want to accept the offer.

However, a buyout can also allow you to move into a new apartment or relocate somewhere else. You also do not have to accept a buyout outright and can even negotiate better terms if you think that the current terms are not favorable to you.

How Much a Buyout Is Worth

Before you accept your buyout or negotiate, it is important to know what price is reasonable for you to ask. New York buyouts have to be approved by city officials to ensure that landlords are not lowballing tenants but a landlord can also take the buyout off the negotiating table if they think that your asking price is too high.

It may be difficult for an individual tenant to determine how much a lease buyout is actually worth. A good measurement would be to compare how much rent a tenant is currently paying with how much rent is currently worth in the vicinity. It may also be good to consider future developments and construction and how much these would affect rent. The market rate is not a fixed amount and is more reliant on how much tenants are willing to pay given an apartment’s amenities and its proximity to other necessary facilities. 

For a rent-stabilized apartment, apartment lease buyouts in general could range from $20,000 to $60,000.

Determining your landlord’s intentions or what is pushing them to offer the lease buyout can be a negotiating chip. When offering a buyout agreement, landlords must disclose in writing the following information:

  • The purpose of the agreement
  • A clause stating that the tenant may deny the offer and continue living in their apartment as is
  • A clause stating that the tenant is allowed to seek legal counsel and provide additional information regarding the agreement
  • A clause stating that the tenant is allowed to refuse contact from the landlord for 180 days.

A landlord can do anything they can to convince you to sign the agreement as long as they abide by the law. As a tenant, it is important for you to know your rights. According to the NYC Protection Act, a landlord cannot subject a tenant to the following acts to force them to accept a buyout agreement:

  • Providing a tenant with misleading information
  • Sending communications or calling a tenant at their workplace
  • Directing threatening, coercive, or harassing language at the tenant
  • Preventing the tenant from entering the building (ie. changing locks)
  • Filing frivolous lawsuits against the tenant
  • Using force or intimidation to get the tenant to accept the agreement

Tenants who have been subjected to such acts may sue their landlord for harassment. Tenants can notify their landlord that they do not wish to be contacted, for up to 180 days, and the landlord must abide by the request or face legal consequences. In addition, tenants can also file a complaint with the City. Landlords proven to have engaged in such behavior may be subjected to various fines. A tenant can receive an amount ranging from $1,000 to $10,000 for a first offense and anywhere from $2,000 to $10,000 for any subsequent offenses.

If your landlord is harassing you into accepting an apartment lease buyout agreement, getting the help of a skilled NYC residential real estate attorney can ensure that the terms are fair and that your rights are protected. Our Manhattan real estate attorneys at Avenue Law Firm are well-versed in the relevant laws involved, including the NYC Buyout and Tenant Protection Laws. We can also assist you in filing a complaint with the City and represent your rights in court if necessary. 

Tax Implications of an Apartment Lease Buyout

Having favorable terms on your apartment lease buyout may seem like a windfall but getting a high tax liability on your buyout can decimate any financial benefits you can get. Being aware of the tax implications of accepting an apartment lease buyout can be just as important as getting good terms on your agreement.

Even though apartment lease buyouts are offered as a lump sum, you may not actually be entitled to the whole amount. You need to be aware of the tax rates that would apply to the payout you get and structure your agreement in a way that reduces your tax liability.

When a buyout is accepted as is, the funds are taxed as regular income and are subject to federal, state, and city tax rates. Finding a skilled Manhattan real estate attorney who can help negotiate and structure your agreement in a way that allows you to benefit from tax rates is beneficial.

Effective Negotiation Tips

When negotiating your apartment lease buyout, you must be aware of the current and future implications of accepting the agreement. The following factors can be useful to keep in mind during the negotiation:

  • Why your landlord is offering the agreement – If your landlord is up against lawsuits, city violations, or is looking to sell the property for a high price, which depends on you moving out, you have more leverage in the negotiation. While it may feel unconscionable to take advantage of such a situation, remember that your acceptance of the agreement will also bring benefits to your landlord. 
  • What is your landlord’s financial situation – Requesting too high an amount on your buyout agreement may not be financially possible for your landlord to meet. There can be alternatives to a lump sum that you can include in your agreement as compensation, such as a partnership agreement on the property.
  • How much you currently pay in rent – If you are in a rent-controlled or rent-stabilized apartment, there is a high chance that you are currently paying below market rate based on NYC rent control laws. Once you move out, your landlord can be free to write a more expensive lease with a new tenant. 
  • Where the property is located – If the property is located at a more marketable location, the demand for housing may increase the rent potential new tenants are willing to pay which your landlord stands to take advantage of. Your landlord may agree to a higher buyout if they expect to gain much by increasing the rent for new tenants.
  • How much it costs to move out and into a new place – Moving out can be expensive and finding a new apartment may also take some time if the buyout offer comes unexpectedly. Factoring these costs into the buyout agreement can lessen your hassle in the future.

Although it would be ideal to assume that your landlord would not be applying underhanded tactics in the negotiation, it is not usually the reality. To protect your rights and to have someone looking out for your best interests in the negotiation proceedings, seeking the help of a knowledgeable Manhattan real estate attorney is crucial. 

How a Skilled NYC Residential Real Estate Attorney Can Help

Getting a handle on all the moving parts of your agreement can become overwhelming. Determining the current market rate for your specific location may also be difficult. An experienced attorney can help you negotiate favorable terms of your agreement while also taking into account the tax consequences.

An attorney can also use legal resources to find out whether there are lawsuits or actions influencing your landlord to offer a buyout agreement. If you reject your landlord’s offer and they resort to harassment to force you to move out of your apartment, an attorney can also file a complaint and a lawsuit, if needed. An attorney can also ensure that your landlord adheres to a request of 180 days of no contact.

At Avenue Law Firm, our team of Manhattan residential real estate attorneys provides quality legal counsel in matters of rent negotiation to apartment lease buyout agreements. We may be able to help you get favorable terms and understand your rights whether you choose to accept or reject a buyout offer. 

Contact Avenue Law Firm today at (212) 729-4090 to schedule a free initial consultation and to learn more about our services.



source https://www.avenuelawfirm.com/what-to-do-in-an-apartment-lease-buyout/

Friday, April 28, 2023

Who Draws Up the Contract in A For Sale by Owner Transaction?

Selling and buying a home can be an exciting experience but it can also be a very expensive process. Sellers may opt to forgo hiring a real estate agent to avoid having to reduce their profits by having to pay a commission. While not hiring a real estate agent to sell your home can seem like a lucrative option, the process of selling your home by yourself can be very complicated. 

You will have to do most of the work by yourself including marketing your home, dealing with prospective buyers and agents, and initiating the necessary legal processes. You will also need to draft and produce the legal documents required to facilitate the sale of your home which can be daunting for someone without the appropriate knowledge and experience. While it is your intention to save money by not hiring an agent, you may end up spending more on fixing costly legal mistakes and real estate litigation. Hiring an experienced real estate attorney can be beneficial in ensuring that your rights are protected.

Working with a skilled Manhattan residential real estate attorney can help give you the guidance you need to sell your home. At Avenue Law Firm, our experienced team of real estate attorneys has successfully assisted New York residents in selling or purchasing their homes. To learn more about how we can assist you, contact us today at (212) 729-4090 to schedule a consultation.

What is a For Sale By Owner Transaction?

When a property such as a house is offered for sale without a real estate agent or a broker, the transaction that commences is referred to as a For Sale By Owner (FSOB) Transaction. 

A seller can save up to 6% of the sale price by opting out of hiring a real estate agent which is why it can be a logical choice for some. While it would still be necessary to pay the buyer’s agent a commission, the cost would be half as much compared to a traditional transaction with two agents.

Sellers who want to proceed with an FSBO deal would have to take on the responsibilities a real estate agent would. The seller themselves would have to determine a reasonable asking price for their home by conducting research on the costs of similar properties around the area that offer the same features as the seller’s own property such as the size of the lot and the number of rooms. An FSBO deal works best in a seller’s market or a market in which sellers have more leverage to price their property due to high buyer demand. 

The seller would also have to conduct repairs and stage the home for viewings, including scheduling appointments for viewings and pooling buyers’ contact information. This also includes doing marketing such as taking photos and putting up listings on property search sites and multiple listing services. It would also be up to the seller to do legwork such as handing out brochures and flyers. It is possible to pay an agency a fee to list the property; however if the seller outright refuses to pay a commission to a realtor, they may be unwilling to show the property to their clients. 

Once a buyer becomes interested, the more complicated stages of an FSBO transaction are initiated. The seller would be the only one to conduct negotiations with the buyer and the buyer’s agent to determine the price and other terms of the sale. The seller would also have to prepare the multiple legal documents necessary to officiate the transaction and the transfer of the property. 

Contract of Sale vs Contract To Sell

The contract of sale is one of the many documents a seller is expected to draft and prepare as part of an FSBO transaction. While the contract of sale sounds similar to a contract to sell, sellers without a real estate agent should take note when creating these documents that they have significantly different purposes. 

In a usual real estate transaction, the buyer and sellers’ agents or attorneys would be the ones involved in creating the legal contracts. However, in FSBO cases, the drafting can go down in one of different ways:

  • The seller drafts the contracts themselves. Under New York law, an attorney is not required to purchase or sell a home. There are DIY alternatives that can allow a seller to draft the necessary documents in a residential sale. However, your buyer may be reluctant to go into an agreement if the contract was not created by a professional. There is also the question of whether the agreement would hold under legal scrutiny if there is a dispute.
  • The seller engages the assistance of the buyer’s real estate agent as a “transactional agent” or “dual agent. In this scenario, the real estate agent would act as a neutral third party to draft the contract. New York law allows for dual agents but with the imposition of strict regulations. Dual agents are required to obtain written consent from the buyer and seller and inform them of their rights and responsibilities as accorded by their agency relationship. While the buyer is the one to pay their agent’s commission, the seller should at least agree to pay a share for the services rendered.
  • The seller enlists the assistance of an experienced real estate attorney to draft the contract. To ensure that the contract is legally binding, a seller can hire a skilled attorney to draft the contract. You would still be paying for the services of an attorney compared to paying a commission but this way, you can be assured that your rights are protected and that you have an advocate who can provide you with professional and legally-sound advice.

Negotiating the terms of the contract and drafting the relevant documents can be the hardest part of an FSBO. Sellers should be aware of their options and consider seeking additional guidance. Regardless of the option you choose, understanding the differences between a contract to sell and a contract of sale is important to avoid jeopardizing the deal or entering into a disadvantageous agreement.

Contract To Sell

Also known as a purchase and sale agreement, a contract to sell is an agreement illustrating the commitment of the seller to sell property to a buyer and the buyer’s commitment to pay for the property. The contract should contain the following:

  • Purchase price
  • Financing terms
  • A complete legal description of the property
  • Closing date
  • Disclosures
  • Contingencies

The contract to sell is an outline of the actions or conditions the buyer and seller must meet. The ownership of the property would only transfer from the seller to the buyer once the terms and conditions have been met. In a contract to sell, the seller retains ownership of the property. 

It is important to note that in a contract to sell, the seller and the buyer can still opt out of the agreement if the other party is not fulfilling the obligations indicated in the contract. Sellers should take note that most purchase and sale agreements are drafted to protect buyers. It may be a good idea to negotiate the inclusion of conditions that protect your interests in the event that the buyer is not holding their end of the bargain.

Contract of Sale

The contract of sale serves as proof that the seller has sold the property to the buyer and relinquishes any ownership they have of the property in exchange for the agreed-upon price. A Contract of Sale can and does sometimes have the same information as a contract to sell, especially the description of the property, the financing terms, and the negotiated price. Once the contract of sale has been signed, the transaction is considered final. The signing of the deed of sale can also be done at the same time as the contract of sale to reflect the immediate turnover of ownership.

Before you sign any kind of contract, it is important to always read the fine print, especially in an FSBO where you won’t have the assistance of a real estate agent. You might be signing away the rights to your home or agreeing to risky terms and conditions that put you in a vulnerable financial position. Depending on the kind of contract and the way it is written, reneging can be subject to expensive fines or can result in extensive litigation. It is strongly recommended that you consider having a competent lawyer review the terms of your contract to ensure that there are no issues.

Working with a Skilled New York City Real Estate Attorney

Even if you pursue the sale of your home without a real estate agent, consulting an attorney can save you the time, money, and energy necessary to learn the ropes of the real estate market in New York City. A skilled attorney can also leverage their experience and knowledge of both real estate law and the market to help you avoid scams and ensure that your rights are protected. Your attorney can also help you avoid litigation by providing guidance regarding New York’s disclosure and housing laws.

At Avenue Law Firm, our team of seasoned New York City real estate lawyers has assisted in numerous real estate transactions both on the buying and selling side. We provide quality legal services, from drafting contracts to representing your best interests in negotiations and fighting for your rights in real estate litigation. We can help you create a contract that reflects your real estate goals and ensure that the terms and conditions are enforced. With the help of one of our Manhattan attorneys, selling your own home can be a hassle-free and pleasant experience. Contact us today at (212) 729-4090 to schedule a free consultation.



source https://www.avenuelawfirm.com/who-draws-up-the-contract-in-a-for-sale-by-owner-transaction/

Understanding the New York City Mansion Tax

New York law mandates a single payment at closing for residential acquisitions priced at $1 million or higher, widely referred to as the ma...